Have you removed other payment options than Paypal though?
Nope. Paypal has been the only option for quite a while now.
Yeah, but at you had another option at the launch of the website, right?
Why'd you get rid of that? :/
What's wrong with your pay pal?
The problem is, I added my card to a Paypal account I made ages ago, and I remember I made a specific email on Gmail for Paypal, but I forgot what the email is.
I've tried to retrieve the email, but it wants some personal information, which is alright, apart from phonenumber. I'm sure I used my old cellphone number back then, and I can't remember what it was.
I can't add my card to a new Paypal account, since it's added to the old one, and Paypal support can't do anything about it.
So I'd have to get a brand new card, which is a bit much really, since I don't really use Paypal at all.